‘Many are called but few are chosen’
Former Humboldt Lacrosse players and coaches can only be elected into the Hall if they attend an alumni game. Only then can Hall members vote the former player or coach into the most rarefied of sporting achievements. Joe Montana may have four Super Bowl rings, but he will never be a member of the Humboldt Lacrosse Hall of Fame.
| Inducted | Name | Years Active |
| 1990 | James Kircher | founder; player-coach 1983-1986; head coach 1992-1994 |
| 1990 | Brian Maready | player 1984-87 |
| 1991 | Steve Smith | player 1983-87 |
| 1991 | Judge Taylor | player 1984-87; player-coach 1986-87; head coach 1987-90 |
| 1992 | Sid Sin | player 1988-90 |
| 1992 | Mike Takeshita | player 1987-89 |
| 1993 | John Mahoney | founder; player 1983-87 |
| 1994 | Josh Jensen | player 1989-92 |
| 1994 | Kevin “KK” Kilkenny | player 1984-86 |
| 1995 | Carl | player 1993-95 |
| 1995 | Jon Hardesty | player 1989-92; assistant coach 1992 |
| 1996 | Philip Pridmore-Brown | player 1989-94 |
| 1997 | Jeff “Dwight” Bedwell | player 1983-86; head coach 1995-97 |
| 1997 | Wes Radulovich | player 1989-92 |
| 2015 | Dylan Rode | player 2010-13 |
| 2015 | Tony Silvaggio | player 1995; coach 2007-2018 |
| 2016 | Jason Foulds | player 1984-1988 |
| 2016 | Cole Aylward | player 2013-2016 |
| 2017 | Sammy Vogel-Seidenberg | player 2006-2010 |
| 2017 | Daniel Balok | player 2012-2015 |
| 2018 | Dillon Sheedy | player 2015-2017 |
| 2022 | Logan Salcuni | player 2016-2019 |
| 2023 | Kerry Sheedy | player 1984-1988 |
| 2023 | Doug Paige | player 1997-2000 |
| 2023 | Sam Barton | player 2012-2013, 2016; coach 2017-2019 |
Post-Season Honors
2022
Ben Jasinski, attack; WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Brandon Nordenstrom, defense; WCLL Third Team All-Conference
Thomas Melonja, SSDM; WCLL Third Team All-Conference
Zack Gamble, goalie; WCLL Third Team All-Conference
Danny Eggert, head coach; WCLL co-coach of the year
2020
Liam Salcuni, attack; WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Zack Gamble, goalie; WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2019
Jeremy Sami, defense: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Vincent Pecoraro, defense: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
Logan Salcuni, midfield: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2018
Logan Salcuni, defense: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2017
Michael Elliot, attack: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Trevor Houghton, defense: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Logan Salcuni, defense: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
Shane Hayes, FOS: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2016
Cole Aylward, attack: WCLL First Team All-Conference
Sam Barton, attack: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Dillon Sheedy, goalie: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Keenan McCarron, defense: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2015
Cole Aylward, attack: WCLL First Team All-Conference
Daniel Balok, attack: MCLA Honorable Mention All-America; WCLL First Team All-Conference
Dillon Sheedy, goalie: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
Juan Climaco, FOS: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
2014
Cole Aylward, attack: MCLA Honorable Mention All-America; WCLL First Team All-Conference
Michael Grady, goalie: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Spencer Knutson, defensive midfielder: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Alex Wilborn, midfield: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
2013
Daniel Balok, attack: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Samuel Barton, attack: WCLL Second Team All-Conference
Will Barton, coach: WCLL Coach of the Year
Dylan Rode, defense: Third Team MCLA All-America; WCLL Defensive Player of the Year; WCLL First Team All-Conference
2012
Daniel Balok, attack: WCLL First Team All-Conference
Jeff Bertotti, goalie: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
Dylan Rode, defense: WCLL First Team All-Conference
Tyler Ulrey, defense: WCLL Honorable Mention All-Conference
Alex Wilborn, midfield: WCLL First Team All-Conference
1999
Doug Paige, attack: WCLL All-Conference
Will Yavorsky, defense: WCLL All-Conference
1998
Doug Paige, attack: WCLL All-Conference
Will Yavorsky, defense: WCLL All-Conference
Thuy Tran, goalie; WCLL All-Conference
Jason Chietti, midfield; WCLL All-Conference
1992
Wes Radulovich, defense: WCLL All-Conference
1991
John Lewis, defense: WCLL All-Conference
Wes Radulovich, defense: WCLL All-Conference
1990
Erik Wayland, defense: WCLL All-Conference
1989
Mike Takeshita, midfield: WCLL All-Conference
1988
Marshall Doud, midfield: WCLL All-Conference
1987
Brian Maready, midfield: WCLL All-Conference
1986
Brian Maready, midfield: WCLL All-Conference
1985
Brock Falkenberg, defense: WCLL All-Conference
Ed Pert, attack: WCLL All-Conference